Tim Herglotz
← Back to the blog
№ 10Human factors · 13 November 2026 · 6 min

The Lag Tax: How a Bad Connection Halves Your Chances of a Creative Deal

A new experiment degrades the video connection for half of its negotiators. Nobody gets angrier and nobody trusts less. They get tired, and creative agreements fall from 74% to 32%.

Topics
Human factors; connection quality; videoconference fatigue; creative agreements; cognitive load; virtual negotiation

Every virtual negotiation I know starts with the same ritual. Can you hear me? You are on mute. Your screen is frozen. We laugh, somebody dials back in, and then we carry on with a seven-figure conversation over a line that swallows every fifth word. We treat it as an annoyance, like bad coffee in a meeting room.

This summer, a paper in Negotiation Journal put a number on that annoyance. Robin Zurbruegg and Lohyd Terrier ran 53 two-person negotiations over Microsoft Teams and quietly degraded the connection for about half of them.1 The pairs on the bad line reached a creative agreement less than half as often as the pairs on the clean one.

The Experiment and the Numbers

The design is simple. 106 undergraduate students formed 53 pairs, one buyer and one seller, with 20 minutes to negotiate the sale of a restaurant. The case is built so that there is no overlap on price: the seller needs at least 325,000 euros, and the buyer may pay no more than 275,000 directly. The only way to a deal is to stop arguing about the number and add something else, for example a paid role for the seller later on or a share of revenue. That is what the authors count as a creative agreement, and earlier research had already shown that tired negotiators find fewer of them.2

For 26 of the pairs, the experimenter’s laptop ran a hidden network tool that added about 180 milliseconds of lag and dropped roughly 18% of the data packets. The authors aimed for a line that was impaired but still usable. No black screens, no dropped calls. Just the kind of connection we all accept on a Tuesday afternoon.

On the clean connection, 20 of 27 pairs (74%) found a creative agreement. On the degraded one, 8 of 25 did (32%). Outright failures more than doubled, from 4 to 9, and so did the negotiations that ran out of time, from 3 to 8. Even when the authors left out the pairs that ran out of time, the gap held: 83% against 47%.

The second finding is fatigue. After only 20 minutes, negotiators on the bad line reported more mental fatigue than those on the clean one (3.03 against 2.58 on a six-point scale), a small but statistically significant difference. When the authors tested whether fatigue explains the lost deals, it accounted for roughly a quarter of the effect, and that result just missed conventional significance. Fatigue is part of the mechanism. It is not all of it.

What Did Not Move

Two things the authors expected to find did not show up, and for my work they are the interesting part.

Frustration did not rise. People on the bad line were no more annoyed than people on the good one (2.44 against 2.27 on a seven-point scale). Frustration followed the outcome instead: those who left without a creative deal were more frustrated, whichever connection they had.

Trust did not fall either. Trust in the counterpart was 5.00 on the degraded line and 5.11 on the clean one, again on a seven-point scale, which is statistically no difference at all. The authors’ own explanation is that their participants were students at the same school, so a shared identity had done the trust-building before the call started.

Put those together and you get an uncomfortable picture. The bad connection did not make people angry, and it did not make them suspicious. It made them duller. They rated the technology as somewhat less reliable, carried on, and then failed to find the deal that three out of four pairs found on a clean line. The cost never showed up as a feeling anyone would have acted on.

What This Means for Building Trust at a Distance

In “Zoom Fatigue Is Real” I argued that videoconference fatigue is filed under wellbeing by mistake, and that cognitive depletion is a strategic weakness. That argument rested on the fatigue literature and on what the sixteen senior negotiators in my research told me about the “tyranny of presence”.3 This paper adds what I did not have in March: an experiment in which the depletion is caused on purpose and the lost agreements are counted.

It also shows where the damage lands. A degraded line did not stop people from negotiating. It stopped them from being creative. In large, complex B2B deals that matters more than it sounds, because the opening positions of the two sides often do not overlap. The deal gets made in the structure: the term, the volume commitment, the payment profile, who carries which risk. That is the kind of thinking the bad line took away. One of my participants described virtual negotiators as “faster but not necessarily wiser”. A poor connection pushes further in that direction.

The trust result needs a careful reading. I would not conclude that connection quality is irrelevant to trust. The cognitive trust my participants described is built from reliability signals over weeks and months: punctuality, clear summaries, kept promises, camera on, consistent follow-up. I set that out in “Why Trust Is Harder to Build on a Screen”. A 20-minute exercise between classmates cannot test it. What the result does tell me is that one bad call is unlikely to be read as a character flaw. Your counterpart will probably forgive the line. The deal will not.

What the Paper Cannot Tell Us

A few things worth knowing before the 74% and the 32% end up on a slide.

The participants were undergraduate students in hospitality management, untrained as negotiators and known to each other. The sample is small: 52 pairs with a recorded outcome. Everything except the outcome was measured by questionnaire after the negotiation, so the direction of some effects stays open. The fatigue pathway just missed significance. And 20 minutes between two people is a long way from a multiparty deal that runs for months.

There is also a question the design cannot answer and that matters in practice: what happens when only one side has the bad line. In the experiment, both negotiators shared the same degraded call.

The authors close by asking for qualitative research, interviews with professionals about what negotiating over video is like for them. That is, more or less, what my dissertation did, and the two fit together well. My interviews describe the depletion in the words of people who live with it. This experiment shows, under controlled conditions, what it costs.

My Takeaways

If you negotiate large, complex deals remotely, I take three things from this.

Treat the connection as part of your preparation, on the same list as the agenda and the walk-away position. A wired line, a tested headset, and a backup channel agreed in advance are cheap compared with a deal structure nobody was sharp enough to find.

When the line turns bad, stop. The authors suggest pausing or rescheduling over pushing through, and I agree, above all for the sessions where you need new options on the table. A status call survives a bad line. A session that has to break a deadlock does not.

And do not wait until it feels bad. Nobody in this study became noticeably frustrated or distrustful, and the agreements were lost anyway. Agree on a simple rule with your team before the call, for example: if we have to repeat ourselves three times, we stop and redial. It is one more practice for the depletion management I described in № 05.

Thanks again, Tim H.

Sources

  1. R. Zurbruegg & L. Terrier (2026), "Can You Hear Me Now? How Videoconferencing Quality Affects Fatigue and Creative Agreements in Negotiation", Negotiation Journal, 42, pp. 392–412. 106 participants, 53 pairs; outcomes reported for 27 control and 25 degraded pairs.↩
  2. Yao et al. (2020), "When there is No ZOPA: Mental Fatigue, Integrative Complexity, and Creative Agreement in Negotiations", Negotiation and Conflict Management Research, as cited in Zurbruegg and Terrier (2026).↩
  3. Cognitive load and the "tyranny of presence" emerged as one of five major themes across all sixteen thesis interviews.↩

Notes

  • Extends the human factors strand opened in № 05. On cognitive trust and its reliability signals, see № 04; on reading the record instead of the room, № 09.

Cite this entry

Herglotz, T. (2026) 'The Lag Tax: How a Bad Connection Halves Your Chances of a Creative Deal', Tim Herglotz, № 10, 13 November 2026. Available at: https://timherglotz.com/the-lag-tax-how-a-bad-connection-halves-your-chances-of-a-creative-deal/

BibTeX
@misc{herglotz2026dn10,
  author       = {Herglotz, Tim},
  title        = {{The Lag Tax: How a Bad Connection Halves Your Chances of a Creative Deal}},
  year         = {2026},
  month        = {11},
  number       = {10},
  howpublished = {Tim Herglotz, entry № 10},
  url          = {https://timherglotz.com/the-lag-tax-how-a-bad-connection-halves-your-chances-of-a-creative-deal/}
}